An email address collected without a dedicated consent box generally cannot be used to market to an individual by email, whatever the collection method. To collect email addresses properly, work in this order: a signup form with an unticked box on your site, a free resource in exchange for the address, a targeted popup, then more occasional formats (quiz, giveaway, trade show, referral). Plan the proof of consent before the first signup.

The legal framework for collecting emails in France
This section describes the French framework (CNIL, CPCE, LCEN), which applies when you market to people in France. The GDPR applies across the EU, and other countries add their own rules on top, so check them if your audience lives elsewhere. French texts are quoted here by their French names.
To market to an individual by email, the CNIL requires prior consent: free, specific, informed, unambiguous, and given by a positive action. In practice, the page shows a dedicated, unticked box with a line such as “I agree to receive [company] offers by email. I can unsubscribe at any time.” Accepting the terms and conditions is not enough (CNIL, prospection commerciale par courrier รฉlectronique, in French; article L. 34-5 of the CPCE, the French electronic communications code, from the LCEN of 21 June 2004; articles 4 and 7 of the GDPR).
Two exceptions exist. A customer who buys from you can receive offers for similar products or services without prior consent, provided you told them at collection that they could object. They must be able to do so simply and free of charge in every message. Non-commercial outreach (a charity, for example) can rest on legitimate interest (article 6 of the GDPR, regulation (EU) 2016/679 in force since 25 May 2018, text on EUR-Lex). Creating an account without buying anything does not make a visitor a customer, as the CNIL states on its page about email marketing.
Every message must name the sender and offer a simple way to refuse further emails. A one-click unsubscribe link meets this obligation.
People keep a right of access and rectification over their data: allow 1 month to answer. One last principle is minimization: ask only for what you use. For a newsletter, the address is enough. The first name can wait.
Proving consent and setting a retention period
Article 7 of the GDPR requires you to be able to show that the person consented. For each subscriber, store in your CRM the timestamp (date and time), the source page, the exact wording of the notice displayed at that moment and the confirmation status. If you change the wording in March, February’s subscribers keep the old version on their record.
Double opt-in (a confirmation email with a link to click) is not mandatory. It remains the best proof. It also filters out typos and addresses entered by third parties. Both modes are detailed in our comparison of single opt-in and double opt-in.
On retention, the CNIL reference framework for managing commercial activities (deliberation no. 2021-131, clarified in its questions and answers, in French) sets 3 years for a prospect, counted from collection or from the prospect’s last contact. A click on a link in an email counts as such a contact and restarts the clock. At the end of the 3 years, you can write one last time to ask whether the person wants to stay subscribed. Without a positive answer, delete the data.
Also keep a suppression list: the addresses of people who unsubscribed, so you never re-import them in a later collection. Storing a hashed version of each address is a common practice for this.
For unsubscribing and the other duties of a sender, see GDPR applied to email marketing.
Choosing a collection method for your situation
Start with the website form and the lead magnet, then add the other methods depending on where your audience is. The table shows the consent to plan for each one.
| Method | Where the address is entered | Consent to plan | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Website form | Footer, article, contact page | Dedicated unticked box | Only one required field |
| Lead magnet | Landing page | Newsletter box separate from the download | The download is not agreement |
| Popup and exit-intent | Window triggered by behavior | Notice and box inside the window | Easy to close, measured trigger |
| Quiz | End of the journey, before the result | Dedicated box at the email step | Ask for the address once interest is built |
| Giveaway | Entry form | Optional box, separate from the rules | Entrants came for the prize |
| Trade show or shop | Paper slip or tablet | Printed notice, date and signature | Manual entry causes errors |
| Referral | Entered by the referrer | None for the referred person at this stage | Do not market to the referred person |
| B2B | Business card, professional form | Information and right to object | Message tied to the person’s role |
Signup forms: the base of an email list
The form remains the method that produces the cleanest addresses, because the person chooses to sign up. A confirmation message shown right after submission (“Thanks, check your inbox”) prevents double entries. Put the form in the footer and at the end of articles, where readers look for what to read next.
For a newsletter, a single field (the email) is enough. You collect the rest later through progressive profiling: after signup, each following visit asks one more question (industry, preferred frequency, interest). The answers then feed the segmentation of your sends.
The button says what the person receives: “Get the guide every Monday” rather than “Submit”. Under the field, the consent notice fits on one line, for example “Yes, I want to receive the [company] newsletter by email”. The wording that gets clicks is covered in our article on calls to action.
Lead magnet: a free resource for an address
A spreadsheet template or a checklist: the visitor leaves an email on a landing page and receives the file. The resource must solve a precise, immediate problem. A 40-page white paper often gets opened once and forgotten.
One legal point you cannot miss: downloading the file does not equal consent to receive marketing. Add a separate, unticked box for the newsletter. Without it, you can send the promised file and nothing else.
Popup and exit-intent
A popup shown after some reading time, or when the cursor leaves the window (exit-intent), catches a visitor who is leaving anyway. On mobile, exit intent does not exist: trigger on a scroll percentage instead. Let the visitor read before you interrupt: a window that appears at page load hides the content they came for and makes them close the tab.
Offer in the popup the same free resource as on your landing page, with the same consent box. A visible close button, an honest “No thanks” link and a single display per session keep browsing from being penalized.
On an online shop, the address entered at checkout serves another purpose: abandoned cart reminders follow their own rules and do not replace the signup popup.
Quizzes and giveaways
A quiz asks for an email at the end to deliver the personalized result. The address arrives with useful information (the respondent’s profile), which prepares fine segmentation. Place the request before the result is displayed and add the consent box at that exact moment.
A giveaway fills a list fast. It also fills it with entrants who want the prize. They unsubscribe at the first send or enter a disposable address. Two safeguards apply: the marketing box is optional and separate from acceptance of the rules, and the rules state how the collected addresses will be used. Avoid importing these contacts into your main list before verifying them.
Offline collection: trade show, shop, event
A dated, signed paper slip that repeats the consent notice is solid proof. On a tablet, the same logic applies with the timestamp. Misread handwriting produces invalid addresses: re-enter them in a spreadsheet and verify them before the first send.
Referral and loyalty programs
A loyalty program collects the addresses of your customers, who can fall under the similar-products exception if the information conditions seen above are met. Referral calls for more care. The referred person has accepted nothing: do not store their address to market to them. Have the referrer send the invitation, with a signup link the referred person confirms alone.
Collecting emails in B2B
Marketing to a professional follows a different regime: opt-out. You can write to a business address without prior consent if the message concerns the person’s role. The CNIL asks that the person be informed at collection and able to object simply, ideally through a checkbox (CNIL page cited above). A named address (first.last@company.com) counts as personal data.
The B2B sources that hold up: demo requests, webinar signups, business cards exchanged at trade shows. The full method is in the article on building a qualified B2B list.
Buying files and scraping are not collection methods. They bypass consent and fill the list with spam traps. The risks are explained in why you should never buy or rent emails.
Setting up collection step by step
- Write the consent notice (for example “I agree to receive the [company] newsletter by email”): the sender’s identity, the nature of the messages (offers, newsletter), the channel (email) and a link to your privacy policy.
- Create 4 proof fields in your CRM (for example consent_date, consent_source, consent_text_version, consent_status).
- Connect the form to your email tool and turn on the confirmation email if you choose double opt-in, with a clear subject such as “Confirm your subscription”.
- Set up address validation at entry (see the dedicated section below).
- Prepare the welcome email that goes out within a minute: it confirms the signup and states the sending frequency, with a visible “Unsubscribe” link at the bottom.
- Test with your own address: signup, confirmation, unsubscribe, then check that the CRM record holds the four proof fields.
Allow half a day for a WordPress site with a single form. Document the result in a record of processing activities (article 30 of the GDPR): purpose “email marketing”, data categories, recipients (your email tool), retention of 3 years. Also note the legal basis, consent. This document is what you show in a CNIL inspection.
Common mistakes to avoid
- A pre-ticked box, or a notice buried in the terms and conditions: legally, consent does not exist.
- A six-field form for a simple newsletter signup.
- Importing a trade show collection without verification: mistyped addresses come back as hard bounces.
- No timestamp: if a complaint arrives, nothing proves the signup date.
- An “Unsubscribe” link hidden in a menu or set in light gray: subscribers click “spam” instead, which weighs on your sender reputation.
- Reusing a giveaway list for a campaign unrelated to the prize.
A sloppy collection ends up on a blacklist: how blacklists work and how to get off them is described in the article on avoiding blacklists in emailing.
Validating each address at entry
An address collected with consent can still be unusable: typo (gmial.com), deleted mailbox, defunct domain, disposable address, spam trap. Every invalid address becomes a hard bounce, and your sender reputation suffers with them. Google asks all senders to keep their spam rate in Postmaster Tools under 0.3% (target: 0.10%). Since 1 February 2024, senders of more than 5,000 messages a day to Gmail must also authenticate their sends (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) and offer one-click unsubscribe, with the List-Unsubscribe and List-Unsubscribe-Post headers (RFC 8058) (Gmail guidelines for senders). Yahoo has applied comparable requirements since February 2024.
Verification at entry blocks the problem before the address reaches your database. With the CaptainVerify API, your form calls https://api.captainverify.com/v2/verify with the entered address and receives a status (“valid”, “invalid”, “risky” or “unknown”), plus indicators such as disposable (throwaway address), role (role-based address like support@) and did_you_mean (suggested domain correction). If the API suggests “gmail.com” for “gmial.com”, show the correction before the form is submitted.
Plan for the slow case: the documentation indicates about 3 seconds for a full SMTP check, up to 15 seconds on slow servers. Set the timeout to 20 seconds and treat a timeout as unknown, which means accepting the signup without blocking the visitor. The API is limited to 2 simultaneous connections and 50 verifications per minute: on a high-traffic site, queue the calls.
For a list you already have, verify it in bulk before the next send. The statuses are described in understanding invalid addresses and the value of the practice in why use an email validation service.
Four-week action plan
Week 1: notice, CRM fields, footer form, full test. Week 2: one lead magnet and its landing page. Week 3: a popup with a measured trigger and validation at entry. Week 4: first segmented send and a look at the numbers (unsubscribes, hard bounces, spam rate in Postmaster Tools).
What is the hard bounce rate of your latest collection today, form by form?

